Sunday, July 6, 2008

Obama on his faith... including abortion rights?

WaPo has a decent write-up on Obama's address to St Louis' African Methodist Episcopal Church. As Obama says, he probably won't win the votes of single-issue Evangelicals who are opposed to gay rights or abortion rights. But there are other areas - poverty alleviation, helping the sick including people infected with HIV/AIDS, stewarding the environment - where Obama is better than McCain. By showing up - and making it clear he is interested in their vote - hopefully Obama can do better than Kerry's abysmal 21-78 loss among White Evangelicals in 2004 (23% of the electorate, and perhaps the difference between Bush and Kerry; Kerry won 56-43 among the rest).

Incidentally, the WaPo also quotes Obama's position on abortion rights, as stated to the AME Church. Earlier, Obama stated that "mental distress" should not qualify as an exception to bans on late-term abortion. Now, this was weird - did he mean only physical threats to the mother's health were reasonable exceptions and a mental disorder/illness was not OK?
So, Obama's fuller position is, according to his statements before the AME Church:

"Historically, I have been a strong believer in a woman's right to choose, with her doctor, her pastor, her family," he said Saturday. "And I've been consistent in saying you have to have a health exception on any significant restrictions or bans on abortions, including late-term abortions.

"It can be defined by physical health. It can be defined by serious clinical mental health diseases," he continued. But "it's not just a matter of feeling blue."

OK... So there are exceptions made for "serious clinical mental health diseases." That sounds much better. And I am pretty sure there aren't women rushing out for an abortion just because they have suddenly had a change of heart - much as the GOP/religious right would try to hype the situation. [My opinion is based solely on my gut - not on any actual knowledge.]
Here's a good comment on the initial report, from a TPM post - apparently by a neonatal nurse.

Not politics? On whom not to marry

Maureen Dowd quotes extensively from a Catholic priest, Father Pat Connor, who counsels people on whom not to marry. Some choice quotes (delivered mostly to women!):
"Does he have a sense of humor? That covers a multitude of sins." - Ummm, does that mean a sense of humor is not good to have?
"Imagine a religious fundamentalist married to an agnostic. One would have to pray that the fundamentalist doesn’t open the Bible and hit the page in which Abraham is willing to obey God and slit his son’s throat." - Oh brother!
And this really hits home, as it is often advanced as a reason for men to marry back in India:
"Don’t marry a problem character thinking you will change him. He’s a heavy drinker, or some other kind of addict, but if he marries a good woman, he’ll settle down. People are the same after marriage as before, only more so." [emphasis mine - RS]
To end:
“After I regale a group with this talk, the despairing cry goes up: ‘But you’ve eliminated everyone!’ Life is unfair.” - Mr Right, or Mr Right Now? :-)

Friday, July 4, 2008

Jay Cost's take on Obama's ad-buys

Via Pollster.com, here's Jay Cost's take on Obama's ad-buys in 18 states. Cost says the aggressive buys in states like Alaska, Montana, North Dakota, Georgia and Indiana show Obama's Chicagoan confidence. Cost however goes on to declare that Democrats looking to expand the electoral map beyond the Kerry-2004 states should follow President Clinton's 1996 victory pattern, playing for Kentucky, West Virginia, Louisiana, Tennessee and Arkansas. These latter five states apparently retain a Democratic advantage in registration, unlike the four red states. But, says Cost, Obama is not advertising here because he lost big to Senator Clinton in the Democratic primaries. Hence, Cost concludes, Obama will either win in a landslide, or lose like Kerry.

Let's look at the facts. Obama has bought ads in Nevada, New Mexico and Iowa - states President Clinton won, but Kerry lost by just 21k, 6k and 10k votes respectively (Wiki). Contrast these with Kerry's losses in Cost's "Democratic 5" - margins of 350k in KY, 100k in WVa, 350k in TN, 100k in AR, and 380k in LA. In addition, President Clinton lost Colorado by just 1.37% or 20k votes (link via the Wiki) respectively, while Kerry lost CO by 100k (<5%). If one was a Democratic Presidential candidate, would one not make a play for NV, NM, IA and perhaps CO?

In one sense, I can see that Cost is suggesting the 2008 electoral playing field will be like 2004, including states Kerry lost by not much. I would also agree that the same factors that cost Obama the Democratic primaries in KY and WV could make Obama lose the two in the GE - particularly racism. As for TN and AR - these two are Clinton turf, which explains why President Clinton won the GE there in 1996 and Senator Clinton won the primaries this year. However, Al Gore could not even carry his home state of Tennessee, let alone Arkansas, even as he won the popular vote in 2000 (Wiki). These factors, combined with Kerry's losing margins, suggest that TN, AR, KY and WV would not naturally be on this Democrat's winning strategy (or that of another Kerry/Gore-type), even in an expansionist plan.

For the other part of the puzzle - Obama buying ad-time in ND, MT, IN, AK and GA. ND and MT may be long-shots, but Obama does well in Western states (CO, NV, NM) - yesterday's Rasmussen MT poll actually has him 5% ahead! The June Alaska polls also have Obama within 5%. Indiana borders Obama's home state of IL and some parts share the Chicago media market, so folks should be familiar with Obama (the IN Democratic primary this year was very, very close). A June SUSA poll has Indiana as a tie, with Obama up 48-47.

Georgia, IMHO, is part of Obama's broader "southern" strategy, together with NC and VA. VA has been steadily turning blue. As an InsiderAdvantage poll (via Pollster.com) write-up says, GA has a high percentage of African-Americans and youth, both of which favor Obama. There is also the Bob Barr factor in GA.

To wit - the past is not necessarily a predictor of future success. President Clinton had his winning electoral map; but that doesn't mean that's the map a Democratic Presidential candidate should follow in 2008. That is the map a White Southern Democrat would follow - if it was 1996.

A decade later, ground conditions and state politics/demographics are different, which means a state like Virginia, which President Clinton did not win in either 1992 or 1996, could turn Blue in 2008. However, even a White Southern Democrat like Al Gore, let alone a Northern liberal like John Kerry, failed to carry the south (which includes KY, WV, LA, TN, and AR). Perhaps this prompted Thomas Schaller to opine that Obama would be the latest Democrat to fail in the south, with the possible exception of Virginia.

However, Obama - as a young Black Midwestern Democrat - has strengths and weaknesses that a Kerry or a Gore or even a Bill Clinton did not have, as well as other factors like eight years of George W Bush, and even Bob Barr. So while NC, GA, IN, AK, MT, ND may seem like a stretch... Not necessarily. And current polls bear this out.

Monday, June 30, 2008

Zinni for VP? (Please, not Wes Clark)

DemConWatch's Veepstakes currently list their final four contestants (after two elimination rounds): Governors Kathleen Sibelius & Bill Richardson, General Wesley Clark, and Senator Jim Webb. As of writing (0030 MDT, June 30), General Clark and Governor Sibelius are neck-and-neck at 29%; thankfully, (sexist-at least-in-the-past) Senator Webb is in fourth place with under 20%.
I wonder if support for Clark has increased as a result of his appearance on Face the Nation earlier today (I suppose technically yesterday), where he said that Senator McCain's military service does not make him qualified to be President. I don't think that is a good line of attack against a war hero, what ever its merits.
But there are other issues that I have with Wes Clark as well - I don't think he did well in the 2004 Democratic Presidential nomination race, which was the only election he has participated in (AFAIK). I am also not sure he has come out with great policy ideas, and I am not sure about his position on the Iraq War. Here's a WaPo column he penned in 2005, and a Democracy Now! interview with the UK Independent's Robert Fisk. I wonder if support for him as Obama's VP is based more on his support for Clinton (as a "unity" ticket) and perhaps to make up for Obama's apparent lack of war/national security experience.
Now, IMO if the VP is not Hillary Clinton, I'd prefer that spot to be filled by AZ Governor Janet Napolitano, or Governor Sibelius. If people still want someone with military experience - then instead of Wes Clark, what about General Anthony Zinni? He's had a distinguished career, and has written well-received books. He apparently didn't believe in or support the Iraq War - here's a Zinni speech in 2002; and a Meet the Press interview in 2007, which mentions his pre-war quote that "these guys [Dick Cheney et al.] don't understand what they're getting into." The same Meet the Press interview has this great Zinni rebuttal to McCain's Surge:

"What has disappointed me is there hasn’t been this debate on the strategy, on the policy, a regional strategy and policy, let alone an Iraq policy. We’re, we’re debating the tactics. The surge is a tactic. In what context is the surge? You can make an argument for a surge if you were going to withdraw, to cover the withdrawal, for example, or to contain, to reposition forces or to re-engage in a different way and a stronger way. And why we got caught up in the tactical debate, in my mind, is an indication that we don’t understand what we want to do. What should our Middle East policy be? What should our policy be in terms of Iraq and, and the war against the extremists out there or the conflict against extremists? We seem to be strategically adrift, in my view."

Though Zinni said in that MTP interview that he would not accept a VP offer, I think it'd be worth making. After all, he apparently also thinks about other issues like climate change, at least in terms of how it would affect US national security.

So - if not Hillary Clinton, I'd prefer Janet Napolitano; if not Napolitano, maybe Kathleen Sibelius; if not, then Anthony Zinni. But please, not Wes Clark, or Jim Webb.

Wednesday, June 25, 2008

McCain's "experience" strategy against Obama, and on Clinton...

Michael Cohen argues in an op-ed in the NYT that Senator McCain's attacks on Senator Obama on foreign policy, NAFTA, veterans' benefits, habeas corpus and other areas smack of condescension. More importantly, they come off as "curmudgeonly" ("crusty, ill-tempered, usually old man"!), and set the bar for Senator Obama so low that Obama is bound to pass it with flying colors, just as President Reagan did against President Carter, and President Bush did against a sighing Vice President Gore.
That is an excellent point - I have had the feeling that Senator McCain scorns Senator Obama. This is apparent in McCain's recent comments that Obama has done well for "a young man with very little experience." [Does McCain want to point out that Obama is much younger? link, link] Besides, experience doesn't exactly translate to good judgment (see Rumsfeld, Don; Cheney, Dick) or electoral smarts (see Clinton, Hillary); in both cases, Obama did better. And as Alan Ehrenhalt writes in Newsweek, Obama does have experience - just a different kind, in state legislature (something Hillarycrats refused to see, and apparently neither does McCain).

In other news, Rebecca Traister of Salon lists 12 reasons why Hillarycrats are mad. Some of these make sense - #1, 2, 8, 9, 11 (except for Geraldine Ferraro!) Some are just irrational; #6: everybody knew - back in 2007 - that FL/MI would not count, and nobody stopped Clinton from taking on sexism like Obama did racism; blaming Howard Dean makes little sense. #10: with the track record of brokered conventions being that the particular Party's nominee lost, would they rather Clinton maybe get the nomination and for sure, lose?
Thankfully, as Traister writes, many Hillarycrats also like Obama (enough!) to support him; otherwise Obama would be polling at 30% or so, not the 50% or so of current polls.
As for Traister's #3 - Hillarycrats will be mad if Obama picks a woman not-named-Clinton as his VP - that's exactly why I suggest Governor Napolitano.

Friday, June 13, 2008

Civil liberties (and Barack Obama, of course)

After yesterday's SCOTUS 5-4 decision preserving Guantanamo detainees' right to habeas corpus, the NYT editorial states:
"It is sobering to think that habeas hangs by a single vote in the Supreme Court of the United States — a reminder that the composition of the court could depend on the outcome of this year’s presidential election. The ruling is a major victory for civil liberties — but a timely reminder of how fragile they are."

As Jeffrey Rosen wrote in an NYT op-ed earlier, Senator Obama may well become the first civil libertarian President. Rosen's similar TNR article (subscription required, via Rojas at The Crossed Pond) starts off:
"If Barack Obama were to win the Democratic nomination and the White House, he would be, among other things, our first civil libertarian president. This is clear not just from his lifetime rating on the ACLU's scorecard (82 percent compared to John McCain's 25 percent). It is clear from the fact that civil liberties have been among his most passionate interests--as a constitutional law professor, state legislator, and senator. On the campaign trail, he has been unapologetic about these enthusiasms. In New Hampshire, I heard him end a rousing stump speech by promising the cheering crowd, "We will close Guantánamo, we will restore habeas corpus, we will have a president who will respect and obey the Constitution." Has a political consultant ever urged a candidate to brandish habeas corpus?"

Rojas, a self-described McCain supporter, takes off from Rosen's TNR article to say Obama is better than McCain on civil liberties, and that libertarian conservatives must be prepared to support Obama on this issue. Rojas, "as a very rigid constructionist and skeptic of judicial authority," suggests civil liberties protections need a mass movement and not judicial intervention - which an Obama presidency is poised to do.

Here's Senator Obama on the PATRIOT Act Reauthorization (2006), his campaign platform on civil rights (which points out, as the first problem, that women, and particularly minority women, make much less than men for the same work), and selected candidates on civil rights.

Finally, Cass Sunstein decribes Obama as a "visionary minimalist" (subscription required, I think). Will read and expand on the Sunstein and Rosen articles later.

Wednesday, June 11, 2008

Combining two favorites...

...MoveOn.org makes an ad tying Senator McCain to President Bush. Starring - John Cusack!
(via WaPo)


However, it seems the ad is airing in the usual places - CNN/MSNBC, The Daily Show, and Bravo. Apparently, Bravo shows popular among "younger viewers, especially women." But these folks already know McCain = Bush! Shouldn't the ad get play elsewhere, so Cusack's star-power is effectively utilized?